Skip to Content

How To Get The Tomato Taste Out Of Chili? Chili Too Tomatoey

How To Get The Tomato Taste Out Of Chili? Chili Too Tomatoey

How to get the tomato taste out of chili? If your chili is too tomatoey, there are things you can do.

It can be pretty upsetting; like me, you might feel you have ruined the whole dish.

Instead of throwing the whole thing out, you might be able to save it.

You can add many things to the chili that will balance out the tomato flavor if you have just added too much.

How To Get The Tomato Taste Out Of Chili?

To get the tomato taste out of chili you can add bay leaves, dried basil, and cumin seeds. Bell peppers and onion cubes can help soak the tomato flavor and make it less tomatoey. You can even add something sweet to counteract the tomato, like dark chocolate, or apply jelly has been known to work well.

How To Get The Tomato Taste Out Of Chili If It Is Too Tomatoey
How To Get The Tomato Taste Out Of Chili If It Is Too Tomatoey

Chili Is To Tomatoey

The best way to know if your chili is too tomatoey is to taste it simply. Taste differs from person to person.

What might be too tomatoey for you might not be for others. I prefer to have a bit of a sour kick to the chili but also a bit of sweetness added. To have it balanced, you will need plenty of spice and heat.

Chili Is Too Tomatoey - Here Is What You Can Do
Chili Is Too Tomatoey – Here Is What You Can Do

What Made Your Chili Too Tomatoey?

Your chili has too much tomato flavor for a couple of reasons:

  • The type of tomato product used
  • The second reason for tomatoey chili is too many tomatoes
Chili can taste tomatoey
Chili can taste tomatoey

The Type Of Tomato Product Used

Most times, when chili is made, there is only one kind of tomato product used.

Fresh tomatoes won’t give off too much tomato flavor. It will be pretty bland.

Canned tomatoes are firm and have a saltwater preservative, making them extra sour and acidic.

Tomato puree is very thick and intensely flavored. They will differ in sweetness and blandness.

You will find a lot of tomato products simply too sour. Especially tomato paste should only be used in chili when the recipe doesn’t taste tomatoey enough.

Too many tomatoes

Adding too many tomatoes or tomato products is the main reason for too much tomato taste. It can be too many sundried tomatoes, too much tomato sauce, fresh or canned tomatoes, or tomato paste.

Some people add a mixture of different tomato products.

In any case, avoid adding too much at once and add little by little. Taste in-between using a spoon and add more tomato flavor if you want more tomato taste in the chili.

How to Make Chili Less Tomatoey

How tomatoey your chili is will impact if you can save it or not. But by any chance, it is always worth a try.

1. Add in Low Overpowering Ingredients

Cumin powder, herbs, and bay leaves can be used either separately or together to help bring down the tomato taste.

When these ingredients are used in combination, they become an overpowering agent. Use them wisely.

To do this, you need to add the ingredients to a carrier oil, such as olive oil then you can add them to the chili.

Stir and wait for the flavor to intensify, then taste and see if the tomato taste is less.

Use cumin powder, herbs, and bay leaves to get rid of the tomato taste
Use cumin powder, herbs, and bay leaves to get rid of the tomato taste

2. Use Curry Powder

Curry powder is mild and lessens a chili’s tomato flavor. All you need to do is add 1.5 teaspoons of the powder to your chili. Taste and add more if needed. Curry powder can be intense, so add small amounts at a time.

3. Add in Onion Cubes

Use 1 cup of onion cubes in your chili made for four people.

Onions will soak up most of the tomato flavor. Leave them in for about 20 minutes, then take them out. The taste should be more balanced now.

4. Add Sugar

Sugar is the main ingredient to add to eliminate too much tomato flavor. It can help with the over-dramatic tomato taste. Add in small amounts until it tastes as desired.

How to Tone Down Tomato Taste in Chili

Here are some tips to help you avoid that tomatoey taste in your chili:

1. Add tomato in portions

Whichever tomato product you are using, add it slowly in portions. Allow time to let it settle. Only then judge the flavor.

2. Add pepper and salt

When adding ingredients to your chili, adjust the pepper and salt dosage. Otherwise, the chili will just taste bland.

3. Add more sugar

If you are using canned tomatoes, add additional sugar.

Adding 1.5 teaspoons of sugar for a four-people recipe will balance the sourness from the acidity in the tomato.

These tips will ensure your chili never becomes too tomatoey.

Too much Tomato Paste in Chili

If you added too much tomato paste to chili, add more water or broth. This dilutes the chili taste. Another thing you can do is add additional ingredients such as ground meat, vegetables, and spices.

Acidic ingredients such as vinegar, lemon, or lime juice can also be added to reduce the tomato paste intensity. in addition, add sweeteners such as chili, honey, or chocolate to the chili to balance the acidic taste.

Lastly, you can always let your chili simmer for longer to get a less intense tomato taste. The flavors will mich and balance each other out more.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Can I Add To Tone Down The Tomato Flavor In Chili?

You can add baking soda, which works well to ward off the tomato taste in chili. All you need to do is add a tablespoon of baking soda to a serving of chili for four people.

How To Enhance The Flavour Of Chili Without Using Tomato?

Add cinnamon powder or brown sugar to the recipe to intensify the chili. Add small amounts to ensure you don’t add too much


To get too much tomato taste out of chili, add:

  • Bay leaves
  • Dried basil
  • Cumin seeds
  • Bell peppers
  • Onion cubes
  • Sugar