Skip to Content

How Long Pumpkin Pie Lasts – We Have The Facts!

How long pumpkin pie lasts?

Pumpkin is not only the symbol of Halloween but also a delicious fruit.

Many people who love pumpkin pie, cannot enjoy Thanksgiving without it.

And as we all know, there is a lot to prepare for a Thanksgiving Dinner so you might wonder if the pumpkin pie will stay fresh and if it’s still safe to eat, if you prepare it early in the morning.

We will have a closer look at the best way to store pumpkin pie – in the refrigerator, frozen, or left out?

How Long Pumpkin Pie Lasts

Pumpkin pie lasts three to four days in the refrigerator. Aluminum foil or plastic wrap should be used to tightly wrap the pumpkin to keep it fresh.

Storing Pumpkin Pie

Once pies have been cut, they should be wrapped in plastic wrap and placed in the refrigerator.

Find out how to tell if your pie has gone bad, including how to store your pie before Thanksgiving.

Pies purchased at the store are generally more forgiving. What’s the reason?

Preservatives, in a nutshell.

On the package, look for the date. In stores, pumpkin pies are kept at room temperature until they expire, so you can store them on your counter until then.

The shelf life of store-bought pies in the refrigerator is about two to four days after their printed date, while the shelf life in the freezer is between six to nine months.

You should treat the pumpkin pie you purchase in the bakery as a homemade pie, because the pie is unlikely to contain preservatives.

How Long Will Pumpkin Pie Last Sitting On The Bench?

You can bake pumpkin pie with either canned or fresh filling.

Pies made from custard, which contains a blend of milk and eggs, are less forgiving than those made from fruit since custard includes dairy products that spoil fast.

Therefore it is not recommended to leave the pie outside of the fridge for an extended period of time.

What is the shelf life of pumpkin pie at room temperature?

When pumpkin pie sits at room temperature for two hours, it decomposes rapidly due to bacteria growing quickly at temperatures between 40 degrees and 140 degrees Fahrenheit.

How Long Can Pumpkin Pie Be Left In The Fridge?

If kept in the fridge, pumpkin pie can remain fresh for about three to four days.

Store aluminum foil or plastic wrap loosely over the products when not in use.

Pies are delicious cold, so leave them in the fridge until serving time.

Whip plenty of cream on top, if you like.

Can You Freeze Pumpkin Pie?

Pumpkin pie can be frozen! If you want to bake your pumpkin pie ahead of Thanksgiving, frozen pumpkin pie will keep for up to a month.

Just follow these steps when you’re planning to freeze the pie:

Using a disposable aluminum pie pan will prevent the pie from getting ice crystals inside it when you freeze it.

If you don’t want your crust to feel soggy, let the pumpkin pie cool completely.

Make sure the pie is tightly wrapped in plastic wrap before covering it in a sheet of foil.

The pie will remain good to eat for a month if it is stored on a level shelf in the freezer.

How To Thaw Your Pumpkin Pie

Removing your pie and its cover from the freezer the day before Thanksgiving is the first step.

It is best to thaw the pumpkin pie in the refrigerator for 12 hours. It is not a good idea to thaw on the counter as this can cause you to have a soggy crust.

You are also opening the pie up to bacteria growth, leaving it out at room temperature. 

As soon as you serve, top off with whipped cream to hide any blemishes.

How To Reheat Your Pumpkin Pie

How about a warm pumpkin pie instead of a cold one?

If you decide you would like to reheat your pumpkin pie right before you are ready to eat it, the best way to do so is to heat it in the microwave for 10 to 30 seconds.

To ensure that the rest of the pie remains safe for reheating, you should only heat the slices of pie that are going to be consumed immediately.

Changing Up The Pumpkin Pie

Make The Crust Different

In the traditional version, a simple pie crust is used, although you can also use other crusts instead of the classic pie crust.

Make an effort to make a difference by trying something new.

If you want, you can cut up gingersnaps or graham crackers into small pieces and mix them into the crust to add additional texture or flavor.

Prepare A Meringue Topping

Whip cream is coming to an end! On top of traditional pumpkin pie, you can layer a thin layer of meringue.

Making meringue is not only a very easy way to make your pie even tastier, but it makes it even prettier as well.

Just How Do We Tell If Pumpkin Pie Is Spoiled?

In case you’re worried about how fresh your pumpkin pie is, here’s how to tell: if there is a different smell or look to the pie, such as watery, dry, or different colored, dispose of it.

Mold can also develop quickly, so ensure you know exactly how long the pie is good for to avoid getting food positioning.


You should always wrap and refrigerate any pie that has been cut.

It is advised that you freeze pumpkin pie if you intend to eat it after its sell-by date.

Now that you know exactly how long pumpkin pie can remain safe to eat for and just where to store it, it means you can make it more often.

If you like to eat it all the time, you can make a few pies and freeze them to eat at a later date.

Frequently Asked Questions About How Long Pumpkin Pie Lasts

Can Undercooked Pumpkin Pie Make You Sick?

Undercooked pumpkin pie can make you sick. Getting food poisoning from raw eggs is possible because they may contain the pathogenic bacteria Salmonella.

Do I Have To Cool Pumpkin Pie Before Putting It In The Fridge?

Pumpkin pie needs to be cooled to room temperature before it can be stored in the refrigerator. Once it has cooled, pop it straight into the fridge before bacteria start to form.