Skip to Content

Cookie Press Not Releasing Dough – 5 Best Reasons and Remedies

A cookie press is a handy kitchen tool that helps you create beautiful cookies effortlessly. It surely is a very useful and convenient gadget, and it has made the lives of many bakers easier, but it isn’t a perfect tool. Sometimes, depending on the situation, we can run into problems in using our cookie press. 

One common problem is that sometimes, it does not properly release cookie dough, and therefore does not allow you to create that beautiful cookie you had envisioned in your mind. What could be the reasons for this? Why is my cookie press not releasing dough?

Read on to find out. 

Cookie Press Not Releasing Dough

If your cookie press is not releasing dough, it is probably because of one of the following reasons: your dough is too cold or too stiff, your cookie dough has chunky add-ons, your pan is too warm, or you are using a greased pan or a non-stick pan. To help your cookie press properly release dough, make you are using the right type of cookie dough that is at room temperature, and that you are using an ungreased, unlined baking pan. 

Cookie Press Not Releasing Dough- 5 Reasons and Remedies
Cookie Press Not Releasing Dough-5 Reasons and Remedies

What is a Cookie Press?

A cookie press is a tool that helps you make beautiful cookies easily. It is a long, cylindrical tube fitted with a plunger on one end that is either manually pressed or electrically operated. On the other end of the tube is a disc or a tip that determines the cookie shape and design. 

These discs and tips can easily be changed, and often, multiple tips and discs are included in one package. This allows you the convenience and flexibility of creating assorted cookie designs just by changing the tip or the disc.

In short, it makes the cookie-making experience easier.

Cookie Press Not Releasing Dough – 5 Reasons

A cookie press helps you create beautifully designed cookies with minimal effort. But sometimes, we can run into problems while using it. The main problem is when it is not releasing your dough. What could be the reasons for this?

There are 5 possible reasons why your cookie press is not releasing your dough. 

 1. Cookie Dough is Too Cold

Refrigerated dough or dough that’s too cold will have a hard time passing through a cookie press and may even cause damage to it. Cookie press dough is easier to work with at room temperature. If you kept your dough in the fridge or freezer, let it warm and thaw to room temperature first before you use it.

2. Cookie Dough is Too Stiff

Cookie press dough should be of the right consistency. It should be somewhat sticky without being too wet. It should be pliable but not too dry. If your dough isn’t of the right consistency, the cookie press won’t be able to properly shape your dough.

You can always adjust the consistency by adding more flour or milk or water to your dough, but to avoid this, it is best to either use the manufacturer’s recipe or use a Spritz cookie recipe.

 Spritz cookies are basically a mixture of flour, sugar, butter, and eggs, and as long as you follow the recipe correctly, these work perfectly with the cookie press. 

Consistency and temperature of the dough are very important to ensure that it will work properly in the cookie press. Too stiff and too cold doughs can clog the cookie press.
Consistency and temperature of the dough are very important to ensure that it will work properly in the cookie press. Too stiff and too cold doughs can clog the cookie press.

3. Cookie Dough Has Chunky Bits and Add-ons

Cookie dough that has any chunky bits mixed in, like nuts, chocolate chips, or fruit, will not properly work in the cookie press. Even if they manage to get in through the tip or the disc, it won’t be the proper cookie shape because the chunky bits will not properly hold the shape.

They can also get caught in the tip or the disc of the cookie press and clog it, causing damage to your cookie press. As mentioned, it is best to use a Spritz cookie recipe, dough that’s just a mix of flour, sugar, butter, and eggs.

4. Your Pan is Too Warm

For the cookie dough to stick to the pan, the pan has to be cold. If your pan is too warm, you can put it in the fridge or freezer first until it becomes cold, and then try again. 

5. The Pan is Greased or Lined with Non-stick Parchment paper

For your cookie dough to stick, your pan has to be ungreased and not lined with any kind of non-stick parchment paper or baking paper. Your dough needs a surface to stick to.

A chilled, light metal pan works best for this. Greasing your cookie sheet will also cause your cookies to spread, which we do not want to happen as we want to preserve the shape created by the cookie press.

Cookie Press Not Releasing Dough – 5 Remedies

Okay, so now you understand what went wrong. What can you do to remedy the situation so you can resume making the beautiful cookies you envisioned?

Below are some tips. 

1. Use the Right Cookie Recipe

If you have used the right cookie recipe and your dough still won’t work in the cookie press, you can try to remedy it by adding a little bit more flour if it’s too wet or adding a little bit of milk if it is too dry.

It is important to add water or flour a little bit at a time until you get the right consistency, to make sure you don’t add too much.

Cookie dough that has a lot of chunky add-ins like chocolate chips and nuts will not work with a cookie press.
Cookie dough that has a lot of chunky add-ins like chocolate chips and nuts will not work with a cookie press. Use a cookie recipe with just flour, butter, eggs, sugar.

 2. Follow the Manufacturer’s Operating Instructions

To make sure you are using your cookie press properly and it will properly release dough, check the manufacturer’s specific instructions on how to operate it. This not only ensures beautiful cookies but protects your cookie press from damage.

 3. Make Sure the Dough is At the Right Temperature.

As mentioned, the right dough temperature is key in producing proper cookie press cookies. Do not use refrigerated dough or dough from the freezer.

If your dough becomes too soft or too warm, you can chill it for a little bit in the fridge. The key is to find the right consistency and temperature for it to be easy to work with. 

4.  Make Sure your Pan is Cold.

If your pan becomes too warm and your cookies are not sticking to the pan, chill in the fridge for 10-15 minutes and try again. Cookie dough will stick better to a cold pan than a warmer pan. 

5. Use an Ungreased, Light Metal Pan.

Do not grease your pan or use parchment paper as the cookie dough will have trouble sticking to these surfaces. Non-stick surfaces do not work well with these types of cookie dough.

It is best to use a light metal pan that is ungreased.

It is important to use an ungreased, unlined light metal pan for your cookies so they will stick to the pan and hold their shape.
It is important to use an ungreased, unlined light metal pan for your cookies so they will stick to the pan and hold their shape.

Conclusion to Cookie Dough Not Releasing – 5 Reasons and Remedies

A cookie press is a great tool to have in the kitchen. If we take the time to understand how it works and take the right precautions for using it and make sure that we use the right kind of cookie recipe, we will likely not have to deal with the issue of the dough not properly releasing into the pan.

We’ll then be well on our way to making beautifully designed cookies that are guaranteed to impress anyone.   

Following guidelines in using the cookie press ensures you are able to create delicious, beautiful cookies.
Following guidelines in using the cookie press ensures you are able to create delicious, beautiful cookies.

Frequently Asked Questions on Cookie Press Not Releasing Dough – 5 Reasons and Remedies

Can I Use Any Cookie Dough For the Cookie Press?

It’s important to use Spritz cookie dough (flour, butter, sugar, egg) for your cookie press. Cookie dough with nuts, chips, fruits, and other chunky add-ons will not work and may cause damage to your cookie press.

Should I Grease My Cookie Pan or Use Non-stick Parchment Paper?

Use only light metal pans and do not grease or use non-stick paper. To hold its shape, cookie dough has to stick to the pan.Greasing also causes your cookies to spread.

How Do You Decorate Cookies Made With A Cookie Press?

Cookies can be decorated with cookie icing, edible sugar, melted chocolate, or candy, and even use edible food coloring pens to design them. There are countless design possibilities.

Author Bio

Daniel Iseli (Head Chef)

Hi, my name is Daniel and I am passionate about cooking. I have been cooking for the past 20 years and am happy to share my best recipes and cooking-related knowledge with you.